
Share
A bipartisan bill meant to speed up energy infrastructure cleared its first Senate hurdle, but tribal rights, Trump's wind turbine hostility, and fears of a fossil fuel giveaway could still derail it.
If you've ever wondered why your electric bill keeps climbing while the clean energy that's supposed to lower costs sits stuck in permitting limbo, the Senate just took a step toward fixing that, or possibly making it worse, depending on who you ask.
On Monday, senators voted 73-25 to advance the Bipartisan American Affordability and Jobs Act of 2026, known as BAAJA. The bill aims to untangle decades of rules that have made it painfully slow to build the infrastructure America needs, whether that's wind farms, pipelines, or the transmission lines that carry electricity from where it's generated to where people actually live. Right now, a high-voltage transmission line takes about 10 years to build on average. Think of trying to renovate your kitchen but needing permission from seven different agencies, each with its own timeline and veto power. That's roughly the bottleneck the grid faces today, at a moment when electricity demand is spiking partly because of power-hungry AI data centers.
The vote came less than a week after Democrats' sweeping midterm victory, and it exposed real fractures within the party. Republicans supplied most of the momentum to clear this first procedural hurdle. The current Congress, one of the least productive in 40 years according to Pew Research, now has a narrow window to reshape how energy projects get approved before GOP leadership hands over the reins.
Supporters call this a hard-won compromise between clean energy advocates and fossil fuel interests, one designed to get projects moving while still protecting communities. But that compromise is fragile, and it's already showing cracks.
Some Democratic senators who voted to limit debate on the bill made clear they're not done fighting. They want changes to ensure the legislation doesn't weaken the ability of Native American tribal nations to have a say over projects affecting their lands. The trouble is, any amendment risks losing the Republican votes needed to pass it. And even if the Senate finishes its work, the bill still has to clear the House, where Republicans hold a thinner majority and Minority Leader Hakeem Jeffries has already signaled opposition.
Then there's President Trump, who managed to complicate things even while the vote was happening. Speaking to reporters, he declared, "I will not approve wind turbines because wind turbines are a major loser." Yet in the same breath, he praised the bill itself as "a great bill that's supposed to be bipartisan," adding, "We are behind it 100 percent."
That contradiction didn't sit well with the bill's Democratic co-author, Sen. Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island. He released a statement warning that Democratic support could evaporate if the administration keeps undermining wind power. "The ultimate success of this bill depends on the Trump administration getting wind turbines up and spinning to get affordable energy on the grid," he said, "and we still need to make progress on that front before final passage."
This tension gets at something bigger than one bill. For years, the environmental movement's main tool against fossil fuel expansion has been litigation, the power to sue and delay. It hasn't meaningfully cut U.S. greenhouse gas emissions. Worse, that same legal weapon now gets turned against the clean energy projects and transmission lines the climate movement actually needs. Supporters of BAAJA argue it's time to stop playing defense and instead bet on cheap wind, solar, and battery storage to outcompete fossil fuels on economics alone.
Whitehouse has been trying to reassure fellow climate advocates that this isn't a surrender. "This bill is the floor, not the ceiling, of our climate and environmental aspirations," he said at a news conference before the vote. "We look forward to accomplishing big things with our big Democratic majorities."

Not everyone is reassured. Many environmentalists had actually hoped the Senate would fail to reach the 60-vote threshold, so that next year's larger Democratic majority could rewrite the bill from scratch. Mar Zepeda Salazar, legislative director at Climate Justice Alliance, put it bluntly after the vote: "This bill was shaped by the very industries that have spent decades damaging our health, exploiting our resources, and putting our futures at risk."
It doesn't help critics' case that one of the bill's champions is Sen. Alan Armstrong of Oklahoma, the former chief executive of pipeline company Williams Companies, who called the legislation his top priority after being appointed to fill a Senate vacancy in March.
Still, the clean energy industry overwhelmingly backs the bill, having been stuck for years in permitting backlogs and grid connection delays. Frank Macchiarola of the American Clean Power Association called the vote "a critical step toward modernizing our outdated permitting process and getting ready-to-build clean energy projects moving." Even groups like Environmental Defense Fund and Evergreen Action, not usually in lockstep with fossil fuel allies, urged senators to move the bill forward. Evergreen's Pete Wyckoff described it as a calculated bet: "In our judgment, the trade-offs right now, as they exist in the bill, are a risk-to-reward proposition that we are willing to take."
Economic modeling backs up some of that optimism. The Center for Climate and Energy Solutions estimates the bill could save ratepayers $2.5 billion annually on residential electricity bills, largely by bringing more low-cost renewable supply onto the grid faster. The bill would also require new data centers to cover their own energy costs rather than passing those costs to ordinary ratepayers.
But Sen. Jeff Merkley of Oregon, who's in line to chair the Senate Environment and Public Works Committee next year, warns the bill could just as easily speed up natural gas plants built to power data centers, or make it easier to build pipelines exporting liquefied natural gas overseas. "Getting more renewable electrons where they are needed doesn't tackle climate change if you simultaneously promote the burning of more fossil fuels," he said before voting no.
Before the vote, the bill's co-sponsors did make changes responding to some of these concerns. The original version let the federal government lock in project approvals quickly, limiting future presidents' ability to reverse course on fossil fuel projects once permitted. Critics worried this handed the Trump administration outsized power to fast-track harmful projects with little recourse down the road. The amendment extended the "look-back period," the baseline window regulators use to judge whether a project is being treated fairly, from five years to ten, which matters because a shorter window would have let the Trump administration's own track record set the entire standard. Earthjustice called the change a "meaningful improvement" but said it "fails to address very serious concerns."
Other revisions addressed tribal nations' worries about losing their ability to challenge projects under federal historic preservation law for damaging culturally significant sites. Some senators who voted to advance the bill, including Catherine Cortez Masto of Nevada and Brian Schatz of Hawaii, say they still want further changes before casting a final vote. Former Interior Secretary Deb Haaland, recently elected New Mexico's governor and the first Native American woman to hold that office in the country, says she remains opposed to the bill even in its revised form.
Labor unions are watching closely too, and largely favorably. The bill is expected to generate more than 100,000 trades and manufacturing jobs by clearing away construction hurdles. Sen. Martin Heinrich of New Mexico, who stands to chair the Senate Energy Committee next year, wore his late father's lapel pin honoring 60 years of service with the electrical workers' union while making his case on the floor. "BAAJA will create over 100,000 trades and manufacturing jobs, good-paying jobs that workers can be certain will be around to support their families through a project's completion," he said.
Heinrich didn't pretend the bill was flawless. "We had to find common ground," he said, acknowledging it was "not perfect" but necessary. That tension, between urgency and imperfection, between unlocking clean energy and risking a fossil fuel windfall, is exactly why this bill matters far beyond Capitol Hill. Whether it ends up lowering your power bill or locking in decades of new gas infrastructure may hinge on amendments still to come, a House vote still to happen, and a president whose support seems to shift by the news conference.
Tags
Original Sources
Senate Advances Permitting Overhaul But Roadblocks Loom - Inside Climate News
↗ https://insideclimatenews.org/news/10112026/senate-advances-permitting-bill
About the author
Amara's entry point into AI was an epidemiology role at a London research hospital, where she spent five years studying how digital health tools reached — or conspicuously failed to reach — underserved communities. Watching early algorithmic systems in healthcare quietly entrench existing inequalities, she redirected her career toward the systemic consequences of AI at scale. She covers AI through an unflinching lens: who benefits, who bears the cost, and what evidence actually says versus what the press release claims. Her writing is calm and precise, but she doesn't mistake balance for neutrality.
More from The Steward →This Week's Edition
11 November 2026
14 articles
Related Articles

Europe's Digital ID Push Tests a New Privacy Tool: Zero-Knowledge Proofs
Policy & Regulation · 5 min

Why the Woman Who Fired Sam Altman Still Doesn't Trust AI's Boardrooms
Policy & Regulation · 5 min

Pakistan to Send Climate Minister to India for First High-Level Visit in Three Years
Policy & Regulation · 5 min
Related Articles

Europe's Digital ID Push Tests a New Privacy Tool: Zero-Knowledge Proofs
Policy & Regulation · 5 min

Why the Woman Who Fired Sam Altman Still Doesn't Trust AI's Boardrooms
Policy & Regulation · 5 min

Pakistan to Send Climate Minister to India for First High-Level Visit in Three Years
Policy & Regulation · 5 min
More Stories
© 2026 Cedar & Bloom. All rights reserved.