
Share
Despite covering 165 million Americans, employers often can't access the best benefits solutions. Industry insiders say economic incentives, not quality, determine what gets shown, and pending federal scrutiny could reshape the landscape.
Employer-sponsored health insurance covered roughly 165 million Americans in 2023, according to the Government Accountability Office. That scale should translate into leverage. Employers, in theory, should command the best available solutions for their workforce.
Reality looks different.
At the INVEST Digital Health conference in Dallas last month, Ali Diab, CEO of independent benefits administration platform Collective Health, laid out a blunter picture. "There are a lot of market forces that are just purely economic, coin-operated, I would say, that preclude the best option from often being shown to an employer," he told the panel.
Diab pointed directly at major incumbents like UnitedHealthcare and Cigna. His company, he said, simply can't match the spending power those larger players deploy to keep competitors boxed out. Transition credits, the payments used to lock in client loyalty, run into the millions of dollars. Smaller independent platforms don't have that kind of capital to throw around.
The mechanics go deeper than marketing budgets. "A lot of consulting firms make a lot of money from their PBM contracts," Diab said. That financial relationship shapes what gets presented when employers bid out pharmacy benefit manager contracts each year. Transparent PBM options rarely surface in those conversations. The same dynamic extends to third-party administrators and specialized point solutions across the benefits landscape.
"The networks want to keep the networks the way that they are," Diab said, "and they want to keep you in that walled garden."
That framing echoes a complaint Mark Cuban has pushed publicly for years. Cuban regularly uses social media to push self-insured employers toward AI tools and closer scrutiny of their PBM contracts. His venture, Cost Plus Wellness, exists specifically to inject transparency into a market he views as opaque by design.
Getting hard numbers to prove a benefits program works should be straightforward. It isn't.
Julie Stadlbauer, chief development officer at Progyny, described a case where an employer commissioned a third-party claims data warehouse analysis to evaluate the company's fertility benefits program. The results were striking: $32 million in savings over seven years, alongside thousands of births facilitated through the program. "So to get to that human value, plus being able to be held accountable for the savings opportunities and ROI, that's necessary these days," Stadlbauer said.
Accountability requires data. Data requires access. And access, according to Diab, often comes with a price tag designed to discourage inquiry altogether.

"You ask a traditional incumbent insurance company, 'Hey, can I get a large claims file?' Or, 'Could you pull these claims for me so I can run analysis?' 'Sure, that'll be $10,000. That'll be $15,000. That'll be whatever,'" Diab said. The framing he used was pointed: incumbents treat claims data like keys to a castle. Letting outsiders in isn't in their interest.
Jason Tibbels, chief medical officer at Lantern Health, brought a different angle to the panel. The customer isn't just the employer writing the check. It's also the employee actually using the benefit. Satisfying one without the other kills the program's relevance.
"Your employee needs to be delighted," Tibbels said. "It doesn't matter how valuable your program is. If people don't use it, it is not valuable. So you have to drive utilization." But utilization alone isn't sufficient either. "It doesn't matter how delighted they are and how much they use it if you're not driving value for the buyer."
Lantern Health's surgical complication rate sits below 1%, a figure Tibbels cited as proof of value delivered to both sides of the equation. He also flagged a more mundane friction point: redundant paperwork. Employees routinely get asked questions their benefits provider should already know, things like where they live, what their deductible is, what plan they're on.
AI can eliminate that friction, Tibbels argued, by pulling existing data directly from employer systems rather than asking employees to repeat it. "People are so delighted when you don't ask them," he said. "You know where they live, and you know what the benefit design is, and you know what the next step is. And then you present them with not 10, but three choices on what to do next."
Smarter use of existing data, in other words, can simultaneously cut friction and sharpen targeting. That's a meaningful efficiency gain in a sector notorious for redundant intake processes.
The structural critique here isn't new, but the specificity is notable. Consulting firm incentives tied to PBM contracts, transition credits that lock out smaller competitors, data access fees designed to deter scrutiny: these are concrete, citable mechanisms, not vague grievances about a broken system.
Federal attention is building. Several bills currently target the vertical integration common among major payers, companies that simultaneously function as insurer, PBM, pharmacy and provider. CVS Health's recent split into two separate businesses drew headlines, though analysts were quick to note that the underlying conflict of interest largely survives the restructuring.
For employers managing self-insured plans, the message from this panel is straightforward: the burden of due diligence falls on you. Market forces won't surface the best option by default. Vendors like Collective Health, Progyny and Lantern Health are betting that transparency and outcomes data become competitive differentiators as scrutiny increases. Whether regulatory pressure translates into genuine market restructuring, or merely cosmetic changes like CVS's split, remains the open question heading into 2027.
Tags
Original Sources
Independent Benefits Platform Leader: Market Forces Prevent Employers From Getting Best Solution - MedCity News
↗ https://medcitynews.com/2026/11/independent-benefits-platform-leader-market-forces-prevent-employers-from-getting-best-solution
About the author
Marcus began tracking AI's market implications in 2016, noticing AI-related patent filings accelerating ahead of earnings upgrades before most of the sell-side had caught on. A former fixed-income quantitative analyst, he spent two decades building models that priced risk across emerging markets before pivoting to cover the economic impact of AI full-time. His writing translates opaque technical developments into clear risk/reward terms — and he's rarely diplomatic about the gap between AI valuations and underlying fundamentals. He believes most market participants still underestimate AI's long-run deflationary effect on knowledge work.
More from The Analyst →This Week's Edition
20 November 2026
29 articles
Related Articles
Related Articles
More Stories
© 2026 Cedar & Bloom. All rights reserved.